home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT2919>
- <title>
- Nov. 05, 1990: A Revolution In Making Babies
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- Nov. 05, 1990 Reagan Memoirs
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- MEDICINE, Page 76
- A Revolution in Making Babies
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>New techniques help childless couples--even after menopause
- </p>
- <p>By PHILIP ELMER-DEWITT
- </p>
- <p> For hundreds of thousands of years, there was only one way
- to make a baby, at least for humans. Either it worked or it
- didn't, and if it didn't, there was little anyone could do
- about it. All that has changed dramatically. The growing
- problem of infertility--exacerbated by a generation of
- would-be parents who put off having babies until their 30s and
- 40s--and the early successes of in-vitro ("test tube")
- fertilization have laid the groundwork for a revolution in
- reproductive technology. Hardly a week goes by without news of
- a breakthrough to help nature take its course. Last week
- produced two such announcements: one offers new hope to women
- with blocked Fallopian tubes; the other promises to extend
- women's fertility beyond their prime childbearing years--even
- past menopause.
- </p>
- <p> Of all the barriers to pregnancy, menopause, which shuts
- down the release of eggs from the ovaries, was long considered
- the most insurmountable. But though the ovaries may shrivel
- like raisins, the other reproductive organs of postmenopausal
- women are still viable. These women can now become pregnant
- using someone else's eggs, according to a remarkable report in
- last week's New England Journal of Medicine. A team led by Dr.
- Mark Sauer of the University of Southern California impregnated
- six of seven postmenopausal women, ages 40 to 44, using eggs
- that were taken from younger women and fertilized with sperm
- from the older women's husbands. Four of these prematurely
- menopausal women gave birth to healthy offspring, one
- miscarried, and one had a stillborn baby--an outcome that
- Sauer said would have been considered normal with six younger
- women.
- </p>
- <p> "The limits on the childbearing years are now anyone's
- guess," wrote Dr. Marcia Angell in an accompanying editorial.
- Theoretically, donor eggs could allow women whose ovaries have
- stopped functioning to bear children into their late 40s and
- 50s. Researchers believe that the new technique will have the
- biggest impact on women in their 40s who have not yet reached
- menopause but have failed to conceive. The new findings suggest
- that these women may be infertile not because their uteruses
- are too old but because their ovaries are, and that with eggs
- donated by younger women their chances of getting pregnant may
- be as good as those of the young women themselves. The hitch
- is, of course, that the children developing from such eggs have
- the genes of the female donor and are genetically unrelated to
- the mother who bears them--a fact that presents both legal
- and ethical problems as yet unresolved.
- </p>
- <p> The other report issued last week focuses attention on the
- Fallopian tubes, the narrow passages that carry eggs from the
- ovaries to the uterus. Women whose tubes are clogged with scar
- tissue or other obstructions cannot conceive by natural means
- because their eggs have no way of getting to the womb. In the
- past, such women had to undergo surgery to have their tubes
- cleared. Now the problem can be overcome in a doctor's office,
- according to an article in the Journal of the American Medical
- Association. With a tiny balloon similar to those used to clear
- blocked arteries, scientists were able to unclog the Fallopian
- tubes in 64 of 77 women, 22 became pregnant within a year. Dr.
- Edmond Confino, who pioneered the technique at Mount Sinai
- Hospital Medical Center in Chicago, estimates that it could
- help nearly one-third of the 1 million American women who
- suffer from blocked tubes.
- </p>
- <p> The new methods join an array of novel techniques that seem
- to multiply faster than test-tube babies. Most are variations
- on the pioneering procedure known as in-vitro fertilization.
- In IVF, eggs are removed from the ovaries, mixed with sperm in
- a laboratory dish, allowed to develop into embryos and then
- inserted into the uterus. The technique has produced 20,000
- offspring since 1978.
- </p>
- <p> But even at well-run clinics, the original IVF procedure
- fails 75% to 85% of the time. The biggest snag comes when the
- embryo is inserted in the uterus, an operation that can be very
- disruptive to the womb. As a result, such embryos often fail
- to take root, or implant. To increase the chances of
- implantation, many doctors are now inserting egg and sperm into
- the Fallopian tube, a procedure known as GIFT (for gamete
- intra-Fallopian transfer). Fertilization takes place not in a
- laboratory dish but in the Fallopian tube, as it would
- naturally, and the resulting embryo drifts gently into the
- uterus, where it is much more likely to be successfully
- received. In yet another variation, called ZIFT (for zygote
- intra-Fallopian transfer), the sperm are allowed to fertilize
- the eggs before transfer to the Fallopian tube. The advantage:
- only those eggs that are successfully fertilized need be
- transferred.
- </p>
- <p> GIFT and ZIFT have turned out to be breakthrough procedures.
- Some doctors who have switched from standard IVF to the new
- techniques have doubled their success rates, which now approach
- 50%. As the odds have improved, the demand for IVF has surged,
- despite the high cost (up to $8,000 a try) and the uneven
- quality of the clinics offering the service.
- </p>
- <p> The proliferation of new IVF methods has produced a crop of
- books to help infertile couples, from Gay Becker's
- psychologically oriented Healing the Infertile Family (Bantam;
- $12.95) to how-to manuals like The Couple's Guide to Fertility
- by Dr. Gary Berger, Dr. Marc Goldstein and Mark Fuerst
- (Doubleday; $14.95). One book sure to cause a stir when it
- appears next January is the new edition of Dr. Sherman Silber's
- classic 1980 primer How to Get Pregnant. In the revised
- version, titled How to Get Pregnant with the New Technology
- (Warner; $21.95), the author repudiates much of the advice he
- gave 10 years ago.
- </p>
- <p> At that time, Silber recommended that couples exhaust every
- other means before turning to IVF. Now Silber maintains that
- the chances of success with state-of-the-art techniques like
- GIFT are so good that almost anything else is a waste of money
- and time. Among the practices he attacks are some of today's
- most widely performed infertility treatments, including
- operations to remove varicose veins from the testicles of
- infertile men and procedures to excise tiny lesions in women
- suffering from endometriosis. Such techniques may be good for
- financing summer homes for doctors, says Silber, but they are
- no longer the best way to give infertile couples what they
- really want: a healthy baby.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-